Beyonce a Poor Excuse for a Wife

In an oped for the New York Post, entitled “Jay Z a poor excuse for a husband,” Naomi Schaeffer Riley asks, “What do you call a man who stands there smiling and singing as his scantily clad wife straddles a chair and shakes her rear end for other men’s titillation?”

Answer: I don’t know—a loser? What do you call a scantily clad wife who straddles a chair and shakes her rear end? Or should this question not be asked since it paints a woman in a negative light?

The closest Ms. Riley came to holding Beyonce responsible was this comment: “It is a little bit surprising, though, coming so soon after Beyoncé contributed to the recent feminist manifesto, the Shriver Report. When she complains that “gender equality is a myth,” one wonders to what extent her consent to sell sexuality has contributed to the problem.”

There’s no wondering, Ms. Riley. Women like Beyonce aren’t just contributing to the problem—they are the problem. This isn’t a chicken or egg scenario. If women didn’t do what they do in the first place, men like Jay Z would have no opportunity to respond—poorly or otherwise. Classy behavior begets classy behavior. Slutty behavior begets a smut reaction. 

You were on to something, though, when you noted this behavior “may simply be the state of relations between the sexes.” The dance between women and men has a specific choreography. In the past, the dance was both smart and dignified. It required a certain kind of behavior on women’s part, which in turn elicited a certain kind of behavior on men’s part.

That dynamic still exists, but the dance steps have changed. You wisely noted a comment by Mark Regnerus, a sociologist at the University of Texas at Austin who says women have struck a kind of “grand bargain.”

“Women get contraception and the ability to limit and space their children, and the chance to fashion careers — things that sound good and are often experienced as such — and in return men get to decide just how invested in a relationship they actually have to be.” The problem is that “men prefer cheaper sex” — that is, they prefer not to be more invested than they have to be.

Indeed, which means women haven’t really progressed at all—at least not when it comes to their personal lives. On the contrary, they’ve simply traded one kind of power for another. They may know what it takes to be successful in the marketplace, but they are clueless about the power women wield in love. Behaving as Beyonce does, or anything close to it, will not produce men who are invested in women. It will merely produce more Jay Zs, or “poor excuses for a husband.”

If women want a quality husband, they might begin by being quality material themselves.

Submit >
Reader Comments
Jan 31, 2014, 11:10 pm

I really like what Miuccia Prada, the Italian fashion designer, has to say about this subject: "With women, the more unhappy they are, the more undressed they are. This is true. Dignity’s another very important part of this. Sex and the City is the opposite of dignity. You have to have dignity for your body--this is with men and women. You need to have dignity towards how you are, how you dress, how you behave." Today's women insist on being given respect and significant roles, but many of them dress and behave in a way that screams, "Don't take me seriously! I'm just a sex symbol!" Ladies, make up your minds; you truly can't have your cake and eat it too.

Jan 31, 2014, 12:44 pm

Why is it that many men these days are scared of their wives? Is is because of a special empathy men have towards women or because most women are extremely materialistic, manipulative and evil?

Jan 31, 2014, 6:28 am

just a typical Hollywood couple

Mike Faralli
Jan 30, 2014, 9:25 pm

Completely agree, Nate

Jan 30, 2014, 8:47 pm

You said it brother!

Jan 30, 2014, 4:32 pm

Beyonce is the same no-singer whose then-group, Destiny's Child, sang the awful "Independent Women" 14 years ago. They also scored hits with a bunch of anti-male anthems.

Jan 30, 2014, 3:10 pm

Beyoncé put cheap femininity on display, a femininity that says others do not need to do anything to earn my most intimate self. All while our daughters we watching to applause.

Jan 30, 2014, 2:41 pm

And the men who really want true love and intimacy are stuck with too many women who have choosen this "cheap" kind of power. This kind of woman wants respect but also a "diva-bitch" role. They don't get both!

Where is Suzanne Next?


Source: The Austin Institute

Source: Julie Borowski

See what people are saying. . .

“Thank you, Suzanne, for having the courage and conviction to be ‘politically incorrect’ in speaking the truth about women, dating and family. You speak for millions of women who don’t have the same courage to stand by what seems like common sense in creating and maintaining a productive society and future generations’ success and prosperity.”
— Michelle

“It is so completely wonderful to hear voices like yours, expressing a truth so many of us know but will never see represented in the mainstream media. Thank you so much for your work, Suzanne.”
— Andrea

“I like what Suzanne Venker has to say. I think women need to really listen to what she’s saying, really listen, and don’t jump to conclusions. She’s not sending us back in time, but forward with a fresh look at who we really are as women.”
— Pamela

“I almost ruined my relationship with my husband when we were dating because of my anti-man attitude. I have now completely converted. Know that you are making a difference!”
— Heather